Sunday, August 7, 2016

iMac 21.5" mid 2011 CPU Upgrade and Repair

At the end of March while the school semester was still in gear, I managed to come across a particular broken iMac at Purdue Salvage. It had a broken glass screen, no hard drive, no RAM, but it was 2011 and it was only going for $100. Against some better judgement, I decided that buying it and repairing it would be kind of fun since I had never actually taken apart an Apple product and I later confirmed that upgrading components was a possibility.

I don't think you can see it very well, but there's a massive crack in the glass that spans the entirety of the screen. I didn't know this until after I took one of these apart that the glass portion of the screen is actually held on to it by some strong magnets. It was really easy to replace and (compared to buying a new iMac all together) was inexpensive to replace. It kind of makes you wonder why they decided to junk the computer.

Purdue Salvage, or the people that handed over to be tossed, decided that removing the hard drive and RAM would be a smart idea then scrapped the whole unit. So the entire process was sort of concerning because I could not confirm if there were other problems with the iMac itself, but I did the initial test of just starting it up and getting the three long(and really loud) beeps that indicated "RAM IS MISSING OR MAYBE HARDWARE IS NOT ACCEPTABLE"

Cascaaaaa
Initially I wanted to install a SSD into it rather than a HDD because it was already kind of an older unit and came stock with a core i5 processor so it could use the extra speed boost. I figured since I was trying to get it up and running again I would figure out if I could drop an i7 into it while I was taking it apart.

As it happens there are a number of different sites and probably dedicated people that have determined what kinds of processors (and probably other components) that can be swapped out of certain models of Apple computer products. Turns out, theory suggested that a core i7 could replace this model of iMac. I was still kind of hesitant however, because Apple does provide an i7 2600S processor which is a low power version of the processor, but they don't mention anything about the "full" version of the i7 2600 processor. Through my power of sleuthing and the internet I was able to find posts from people that allegedly replaced their processors with the standard core i7 2600 cpu, but no one showed any screenshots of this proving one way or the other. Come on internet, provide proof of these sorts of things. How else could you be trusted?


|_?_|
 This was a pretty good sign. I tried using Other World Computing's HDD to SSD upgrade kit for my model of iMac. Unfortunately, I ran into some different problems. So, you can't use the Snow Leopard disk to install OSX because support for SSD wasn't available. Well that's okay, I have a Macbook Air with El Capitan and created an install USB drive with it. Try again, well, it managed to get past boot up and I was able to get to disk utility, but for some reason or another it managed to fail at the last portion of install. I still haven't determined why. I managed to get a lot of useful information and support from MacSales though. I spoke with someone named Bob Boldt with their sales team, not only is he awesome, but the entire staff that I've seen is incredibly helpful. I would strongly suggest that if you have any mac related issues/projects to check with them. They really do deserve it, credit where credit is due.
Disk Utility didn't really help here


As a little side note, the first time I tried to install using the OSX disk, the drive didn't want to return it to me so I had to operate to remove it.



Rauschach
 Anyways, after struggling with the SSD so long, I gave up and decided that I should just use one my left over HDD that I have sitting around with some outdated version of Linux on it. It managed to install El Capitan no problem. Hooray. I wanted to install OSX first before I opened the computer up to do cpu surgery because up to this point I didn't even know if the computer was functional. Now on to the surgery.




To harvest the organsslowly killing it
 More useful information OWC has on their website, instructional videos (that's a direct vimeo link to the video that I found useful) that step you through installing their SSD. It is a cleverly disguised video that shows you how to install one of their SSD kits, but in reality it shows you how to take out the motherboard so that you can perform serious surgery. Apple did a good job at making everything compact and fit into it's little box, but like anything that is engineered to be compact becomes really difficult to use intuition to take apart. It's a shame they don't provide the information easily to repair their units.

Time to take you apart
There's the meat of it. Really nice, small, and a funny shaped head. The cpu is under that square bit (the heatsink) there on the right. There's a sticker that says, "warranty void if removed", but I'm not really sure what that means. I suspect it means this screw is the important one. Once you unscrew the four screws(Torx) you get access to the cpu and the rest is like replacing any other cpu in a computer.




Warranty Voided
Proof is in the Puddin'Nice! Although, in my opinion they used probably way too much thermal paste on the original cpu, cleaning it up and replacing was pretty simple. Be sure to make sure that you have the orientation correct. I nearly put it in flipped(180 degrees rotated not flipped) until I reviewed some of my photos to double check. Always be thorough. Good advice to anyone for
anything... probably.

There see? Proof. You might have to look closely, but the top of the processor it says core i7 2600. Not 2600S, not core i5, it says i7 2600. It can be done. "But Steve that doesn't prove that it works." I hear you cry.

As I'm typing this post on my newly refurbished iMac, I can definitively say that the iMac 21.5" mid 2011 will accept the core i7 2600 processor and it is definitely not on fire.

3.4 Giggle Herts

I cut out the bit with the serial number. I am not sure if that's useful information to others, but if it is I probably don't want them to have it.

There it is. Core i7 2600 in an iMac that probably isn't supposed to have it in there. I haven't given up completely on the SSD, I'm going to be working on getting the SSD installed again and seeing if I can install OSX on it as the secondary drive. If that's successful, then I can make the HDD the secondary storage drive using the SSD for the main system. I also have been finding information about replacing the graphics card in this unit. Do I need it? Probably not, but I don't see why it wouldn't help or be a bad idea. This is now my little Frankintosh... ugh, that's a way better name than calling it Rorschach... why did I think of this now?

This was kind of fun, so if I figure out more information on a graphics card upgrade/replacement, I may make another blog post about it. I'll edit this post once I can get the SSD installed properly the way I want it to be. What did I learn from this? I learned that the cpu fan likes to be on all the time now and it is super loud, but that's okay because I have headphones for this sort of thing.

15 comments:

  1. Per the SSD issues: I don't know what the limitations of `rsync` are for OSX, but you might be able to install the SSD as a secondary hard drive and use rsync to clone the entire up-and-running system over to the SSD and then just set that up as your primary drive. Then just swap them out. Would not surprise me if that was incredibly difficult though, because Apple is ridiculously restrictive when it comes down to root permissions.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was thinking something along the same lines. I hope it works, but I need an SSD power cable to get the proper connector. I hope to have it looked into by sometime before next weekend.

      Delete
    2. Good luck dude! I hope to see more stuff like this. I've got a MacBook Pro from the same year and I just upgraded the RAM to 16GB, next on the to do list is upgrade to a SSD (unfortunately that's about the extent of what I can do as the CPU is permanently fixed to the mobo).

      Delete
  2. Thank you for posting this article! I've been thinking about doing this myself and have never found any solid documentation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree. I've read through forums where different people have said it was possible or they've done the modification themselves but I really wanted confirmation all in one place that showed that it worked... and didn't catch on fire.

      Delete
  3. Thank you thank you thank you.

    The only thing is that the TDP on the i7 is around 35W higher, do you have any trouble with over heating or unstable due to power supply not able to keep up?

    By the way, SSD install definitely possible. I even link up the SSD and the HDD to become a Fusion drive. You should keep at it. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. So far no issues with stability or overheating although I suspect it does run hotter than before. Unfortunately I didn't think to measure internal temperature before and after.

      The power supply is most likely overloaded, but it isn't under powering the i7. At worst, it will shorten the lifespan of the power supply, but I want to believe not to such a degree that I might have to replace it in a year.

      In the event it does over heat, I kind of want to humor the idea of installing a contained water cooling system. It would require putting holes somewhere and figure out a mounting strategy, but I believe it would be possible.

      Delete
    2. I would imagine it to be insanely difficult given how the CPU/logic board have to put back into the casing/chassis. I would maybe cut open the rear of casing behind the optical drive (where many would mount an SSD) for mounting the radiator. It's pretty crowded everywhere else.

      Delete
    3. I agree. I don't think I could get it all contained inside the chassis easily without heavy modification. It might even require the radiator to be mounted outside the case. Fortunately, I don't have to think about it, but if I do I'll be sure to post my success/failure on the project.

      Delete
  4. Hey Steven, thanks for a great article. I'm interested in doing this for my father's iMac 2011 21.5 so that he can play back 4K video better. I caught this little blurb at the end: "I learned that the cpu fan likes to be on all the time now and it is super loud". Since you are not using the original HD in the machine, that's likely the HDD fan. Without an Apple-supplied drive and specific temperature monitoring, that fan will ramp up to full speed. Whenever I install SSDs in these systems, I use SSD Fan Control from http://exirion.net, then set temp monitoring to SMART. I wouldn't want my dad's fans going full blast from just the CPU...you wanna try SSD Fan Control and reply if that knocks out the fan noise? Thanks again!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dang. I don’t know why it took me so long to respond, I’m going to blame exams. Thanks for the tip. Since most of my academic work sort of requires the use of a windows machine I hardly ever use my iMac unfortunately. If I ever get around to messing with this again, I’m definitely going to try fan control. Thanks!

      Delete
  5. Hi Steven, thanks for the article! How is it going with the i7-2600 after this years?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Steven, i too picked up a imac 21.5 2011 with an i5. and would like to upgrade, i liked your article ,i also was wondering if you will be continuing the project ~ Will

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. All of my projects, in some capacity, are on going. Most of them are in some form of indefinite hiatus until I can find more tinker time. I hope to expand these posts further eventually, however when that may be is somewhat in the air.

      Delete